The Best Seafood in Tilghman Island, Maryland

By Seafood Market Direct Editorial Team · Updated May 2026

A ranked guide to 7 top seafood markets, restaurants, and docks in Tilghman Island, drawn from 19 community-tracked price reports and our directory of 9 active listings.

How we rank

Our ranking blends signals we can verify from public listings: whether the business is a verified or admin-approved listing on our directory, how many recent community-reported prices it has tracked, whether it operates a public website, whether community members added it directly, and whether the business has published its specialties. No money changes hands for ranking position — listings are scored purely on data signals that any visitor can check on the business's profile page.

  1. 1

    Tickler's Crab Shack & Restaurant Restaurant

    Tilghman Island, MD 21671 · Website

    19 community-tracked prices; recent crab average $24.00.

    Crab $24.00 Oyster $21.00 Fish $28.00
  2. 2

    Knapp’s Narrows Marina & Inn Market

    Tilghman Island, MD 21671 · Website

    Active local listing.

  3. 3

    The Tilghman Island Inn Restaurant

    Tilghman Island, MD 21671 · Website

    Active local listing.

  4. 4

    Big Mack's Kitchen & Dock Bar Restaurant

    Tilghman Island, MD 21671 · Website

    Active local listing.

  5. 5

    Fairbank Tackle Market

    Tilghman Island, MD 21671 · Website

    Active local listing.

  6. 6

    Two if by Sea Restaurant

    Tilghman Island, MD 21671 · Website

    Active local listing.

  7. 7

    Wylder Hotel Tilghman Island Market

    Tilghman Island, MD 21671 · Website

    Active local listing.

See all listings in Tilghman Island Search by ZIP or area